Trial Evidence Chart To Kill A Mockingbird Resource 4.6 Answers
Introduction
"To Kill a Mockingbird" is a novel written by Harper Lee. The book was published in 1960 and has since become a classic in American literature. The story is set in the 1930s in a small town in Alabama and revolves around the trial of Tom Robinson, a black man accused of raping a white woman. The novel tackles themes of racism, injustice, and the loss of innocence. As part of the study of the book, students are often asked to complete resource 4.6, which is a trial evidence chart. This article will provide answers to resource 4.6 and will help students understand the trial evidence chart better.
Resource 4.6
Resource 4.6 is a trial evidence chart that students are asked to complete while studying "To Kill a Mockingbird." The chart requires students to list the evidence that is presented during Tom's trial and to analyze how the evidence supports or disproves Tom's guilt. The chart is divided into three categories: physical evidence, testimony, and circumstantial evidence. Students are required to list the evidence under each category and to explain how it supports or disproves Tom's guilt.
Physical Evidence
The physical evidence presented during Tom's trial is limited. The only physical evidence presented is the bruise on Mayella Ewell's face. The defense argues that the bruise is not consistent with Tom's left hand, which is crippled. The prosecution argues that the bruise is consistent with Tom's right hand. However, the defense points out that Tom's right hand is not strong enough to have caused the bruise. Therefore, the physical evidence is inconclusive in proving Tom's guilt.
Testimony
Testimony plays a significant role in Tom's trial. The prosecution presents testimony from Mayella Ewell, Bob Ewell, and Sheriff Heck Tate. Mayella testifies that Tom raped her, while Bob testifies that he saw Tom run away from his house on the night of the alleged rape. Sheriff Tate testifies that he found no evidence of rape at the scene. However, the defense presents testimony from Tom Robinson, who maintains his innocence. He explains that he was helping Mayella with some chores and that nothing inappropriate happened. Tom's testimony is credible, and the prosecution's witnesses are unreliable. Therefore, the testimony is inconclusive in proving Tom's guilt.
Circumstantial Evidence
The circumstantial evidence presented during Tom's trial is weak. The prosecution argues that Tom's motive for raping Mayella was revenge for her advances towards him. However, there is no evidence to support this claim. The defense argues that Mayella's injuries were consistent with someone who had been beaten by a left-handed person. This evidence suggests that Mayella's injuries were caused by her father, Bob Ewell, who is left-handed. Therefore, the circumstantial evidence is inconclusive in proving Tom's guilt.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the trial evidence chart for "To Kill a Mockingbird" resource 4.6 provides students with an opportunity to analyze the evidence presented during Tom's trial. The physical evidence, testimony, and circumstantial evidence are inconclusive in proving Tom's guilt. This fact highlights the book's themes of racism and injustice, as Tom is convicted solely based on his skin color and not on the evidence presented during his trial. By completing resource 4.6, students can gain a better understanding of the trial and its significance in the book.